Karachi Photo Blog

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Can someone come up with a coherent story about Mumbai attacks, please?

While the US celebrated Thanksgiving Mumbai was under attack. Terrorists’ assault on India’s financial hub brought the country of over billion people to almost a halt. But two weeks after the carnage we are still waiting for a coherent story from the Indian establishment. Who were those attackers? The official story tells you these men were of Pakistani origin who were trained in a militant camp in Pakistan ran by a banned group. But you should not be in any hurry to accept this version because it has changed many times. While the terrorists were still on their rampage, Indian police claimed they were Pakistanis. And then we were told they were British passport holders of Pakistani descent. And then the identity documents changed to Mauritius ID cards and then to Malaysian passports. And a couple of days ago we were told Pakistani identity cards have been confiscated from the dead terrorists. The last claim would make the terrorists very smart and very dumb at the same time. They were smart enough to carry out a sophisticated, highly coordinated operation, but dumb enough to carry their Pakistani identity cards with them.

How did the assailants reach India? The loudest version of the story tells you these men reached the shores of India in a boat and went straight to execute their terror plot. But then another version tells you at least one terrorist checked in Taj Mahal Hotel as a guest and used his room to store ammunition—and it makes sense because the amount of ammunition used (hand grenades and rounds after rounds of AK47) would be very hard to carry in a rubber boat and then to carry along on person, while trying to locate the targets in a teeming metropolis. But then which one is it: quick and dirty rubber boat trip, or a long operation that required hammering out logistics for days before embarking on the plan?

The official story is still being refined as I write these lines. Now we are told the terrorists carried fake identity cards of an Indian college. Should the rubber boat part of the story be forgotten now?

And then there is this phone call to a TV channel from a person claiming to be one of the terrorists killing people in Nariman House. You got to listen to it on YouTube to understand how enigmatic the clues given in that phone call are. Can someone from the Indian establishment please give this segment of the gory episode a credible spin?

In short, while the world is patiently waiting for the Indian government to get its story together, our sole link to the truth behind Mumbai attacks is Ajmal Kasab (if that indeed is his real name), the only terrorist purportedly captured alive. Pakistan and the international community must demand talking directly to this man. A conversation with this man might be the only way to find out what actually transpired in Mumbai.

And we must also fear what would ultimately happen in India, in the aftermath of Mumbai attacks. One particular part of the Indian establishment would use this opportunity to not only suppress its largest religious minority, it would come hard on all separatist movements raging in various parts of that country.

Photo, courtesy of Reuters.



At Fri Dec 12, 02:22:00 AM PST, Anonymous Anonymous said...

May be reading dawn news interview of ajmal's father would help you convince yourself of his real name.

maybe pakistan's security forces can start finding out more abt whats happening in their own country before asking for coherent version of mumbai attacks. don't u think its practically irrelevant in what order ajmal killed who, or what fake ids he carried once u know his real identity, and find out who used him to do it? indians can't come to pakistan and find out where he was and what he did and how he trained and who trained him etc etc. pakistan can investigate, collect the evidence.

unless u r only interested in diversion.

At Fri Dec 12, 08:32:00 AM PST, Blogger Cemendtaur said...

Thanks for the feedback, Anonymous.
When lives of 180 innocent people have been taken, we are very gullible to accept any story woven around the tragedy--provided the story is coherent. And right now the story being told has holes in it...big holes.
Look at the picture of this man walking. We are told he is 'Ajmal Kasab'. Compare this picture of Kasab with the one taken in the hospital.
The two faces do not match.

We know police in our part of the world--they can arrest anyone and beat them up to own any identity.

Here is the right way to go:


At Tue Dec 16, 10:25:00 PM PST, Blogger Cemendtaur said...

Please also see a relevant post here:

At Fri Jul 24, 12:29:00 PM PDT, Blogger Anirban said...

yknow the only similarity between you guys and us guys? we both get killed by pakistani terrorists. so its not that hard to understand why everyone hates you losers. if youd use your brains a little bit, you could think about who has more to lose from terrorism in south asia. a failed state (that would be you chaps) or a trillion dollar economy thats growin at 8 percent

At Fri Jul 24, 12:29:00 PM PDT, Blogger Anirban said...

This comment has been removed by the author.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home